| |

ANA Urges FCC To Reject Overly Expansive Reading Of Children's TV Rules

Washington, D.C. (October 22, 2010) - The ANA (Association of National Advertisers), the 4As and the American Advertising Federation (AAF), representing a broad group of marketing and media companies, have urged the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) to reject the false premise that any animated characters originally tied to products inherently constitute advertising and cannot appear in children's television programming.  The industry comments were filed in response to a petition from the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood (CCFC) seeking a declaratory ruling from the FCC that the Zevo-3 program created by Skechers Entertainment is a "program length commercial" that violates the advertising limits of the Children's Television Act.

ANA Executive Vice President, Government Relations Dan Jaffe stated: "The FCC has long recognized the need to enforce its children's TV policies in a way that does not restrict the ability to draw characters from many different sources.  The CCFC petition asks the FCC to adopt a rigid rule that would effectively ban any animated characters with ties to products from appearing in children's TV programs under any circumstances.  Allowing the government to regulate the origins of fictional characters in children's programming is intrusive, unwise and raises serious First Amendment concerns."
The comments were written by First Amendment expert Robert Corn-Revere, a partner with the law firm of Davis Wright Tremaine, LLP.
The filing noted that Zevo-3 is no different from shows like He-Man, G.I Joe or the California Raisins that may involve pre-existing characters based on products.  The FCC has been able to avoid intruding on editorial judgments of programmers by relying on objective standards for separating programs from advertising, through commercial time limits, the requirement of 'bumpers' and the prohibition of 'host selling' by a program's talent or characters.   
Further, the industry comments note that the Commission has specifically rejected the regulatory approach urged in the CCFC petition: "The Commission's existing policy governing children's programming recognizes that so long as adequate safeguards prevent direct intermixture of commercial and program segments and a good-faith belief exists that a program will entertain, there is 'no useful purpose' in restricting how programs are developed, selected and aired."   

Jaffe concluded: "If this proposal were to be accepted by the FCC, it would place unnecessary limits on program character creation, totally reverse longstanding FCC policies and erode an important source of financial support for children's programming."
The industry comments are available here.

Primary press contact:

Lesley Neadel
CooperKatz & Company

Legislative and Regulatory Issues Tracking

ANA's Washington, DC office works to protect the ability of all marketers to communicate effectively with consumers.   The scope of legislation, regulations, and court cases impacting the marketing community continues to be extremely broad, extending to issues as diverse as online privacy, prescription drug advertising, restrictions on the tax deductibility of advertising costs and the regulatory powers of the Federal Trade Commission.

Read more >

Compendium of Legislative, Regulatory and Legal Issues

ANA's Washington, DC office plays a leading role in protecting the ability of all marketers to communicate effectively with consumers. At the end of each year, we prepare a Compendium which describes our efforts on the broad range of issues we have faced. 

Read more >

Alliance for Family Entertainment

The ANA Alliance for Family Entertainment (AFE) is a coalition of national advertisers, supported by the ANA, which represents almost 40% of all U.S. television advertising dollars..

Learn more >


ANA and the American Association of Advertising Agencies (4A’s) conduct broadcast talent negotiations with the Screen Actors Guild (SAG) and the American Federation of Television and Radio Artists (AFTRA) through the Joint Policy Committee, or JPC.

Learn more >